Construction Defect

An allegation is not a finding.

A construction defect claim starts with an allegation. YA Group's multidisciplinary experts establish what actually happened, clarifying cause, resulting damage, responsibility, and the appropriate path to repair.

Three questions behind every claim

The defect is only the beginning

01 The observed condition

What failed and what's wrong?

The visible condition or initial allegation: Water intrusion, cracking, material deterioration, system failure, non-compliant installations, or other observed conditions may point to a construction defect, but they do not necessarily explain why the conditions occurred.

02 The contributing factors

Why did it fail and why is it wrong?

The technical investigation into design, materials, installation, environmental conditions, maintenance, manufacturer requirements or instructions, code requirements, and interfaces between building systems can offer insights into how and why a defect occurs. Determining the cause aids in identifying the responsible party and drives the remedial scope of work.

03 The claim impact

What does it mean for the claim?

Understanding the allegations of defects and damages, the extent of the defects, the cause, and responsible parties provides owners, insurers, and litigators with the information they need to make decisions on the course of the claim and litigation.

How a defect claim unfolds

From allegation to resolution

  1. The claim begins

    Allegation

    Construction defects can result in damage, deterioration, or functional loss, often prompting investigations that uncover additional deficiencies, including non-compliant work and resulting damage.

  2. Evidence is gathered

    Investigation

    Through site observations, historical data analysis, and specialized testing, YA Group investigates construction defect allegations to verify conditions and determine the extent of defects and resulting damage.

  3. Cause is established

    Causation

    Identifying the underlying causes of construction defects helps establish responsibility, guide repair strategies, and support claims and litigation resolution.

  4. Exposure takes shape

    Repair Scope

    Drawing on investigative findings, applicable standards, and construction practices, YA Group develops practical repair scopes and cost estimates to address identified defects and damage.

  5. The claim closes

    Resolution

    Defensible technical findings support negotiation, mediation, or testimony at deposition and trial, and hold up under cross-examination.

A construction defect claim is rarely one discipline's problem. The condition someone reports is usually the end of a chain that runs back through design, materials, installation, and years of exposure. Our job is to follow that chain until the evidence says where it started, and then to explain it plainly enough that it holds up under cross-examination.
Matthew Watson | Managing Partner
Multidisciplinary Expertise

The right expertise at every stage of the claim.

Our civil, structural, and geotechnical engineers evaluate building systems, structural conditions, site-related issues, and alleged deficiencies to determine how design, construction, materials, or subsurface conditions may have contributed to a failure.

Keep your credentials current

Construction Defect Continuing Education for Adjusters and Attorneys

Construction defect claims turn on building science: how water moves through an envelope, why roofing systems fail, and which code requirements applied when the structure was built. YA Group teaches these subjects as accredited continuing education for insurance adjusters and attorneys, drawing on the forensic casework our engineers handle every day in construction defect investigation. Courses are scheduled for your team on request.

See all continuing education courses from YA Group

Need clarity on a construction defect claim?

The right technical insight can help bring clarity to complex construction defect matters. Explore our construction defect courses for practical guidance on common issues, or engage YA Group to evaluate causation, damage and repair scope, and provide defensible technical findings to support your case.
See the evidence in action

Construction defect claims, and what the findings changed